Which is better for permanent girth , Pumping or clamping ??

[snakehead]

As of now i perform both clamping and pumping but if you had to pick 1 which one would it be ??

[bored]

Do you pump before clamping or after? I would think before.

Sorry, I'm not experienced enough to give a definitive answer for you

[snakehead]

I will clamp then pump. I also combine hanging as well, Hang , clamp ,Then pump thats if i have time , very time consuming.

[bored]

Well, I know donjelqer did clamping with the Bathmate afterward
http://www.pegym.com/forums/blogs/do...1-15-2011.html and you can see he had good results in girth. http://www.pegym.com/forums/blogs/do...37-3-gain.html

[TJM19]

Based on my research, pumping is not great for permanent gains. I have pumped a decent amount of times and have only noticed a better flaccid hang and maybe better EQ. I must admit, it is GREAT for a flaccid hang. I have no experience with clamping though.

[thatnewnew]

Based on my research, pumping is not great for permanent gains. I have pumped a decent amount of times and have only noticed a better flaccid hang and maybe better EQ. I must admit, it is GREAT for a flaccid hang. I have no experience with clamping though.

I have heard mixed reviews of pumpings ability to cause permanent gains. The research i have done suggests most of pumping gains last only between 5min-1hour But on this forum ive seen people claim great gains in girth due to pumping.

[TJM19]

I have heard mixed reviews of pumpings ability to cause permanent gains. The research i have done suggests most of pumping gains last only between 5min-1hour But on this forum ive seen people claim great gains in girth due to pumping.

Pumping alone probably wont give you permanent results but if you mix it with manual PE it can increase gains.

[Steve23]

Expecting fast gains from pumping just because you see a plumpness isn't good, now if you keep a nice pumping routine for 9 months or so then you will be getting gains and cementing it slowly.

[not2big]

Expecting fast gains from pumping just because you see a plumpness isn't good, now if you keep a nice pumping routine for 9 months or so then you will be getting gains and cementing it slowly.

A agree completely. I gained over .25 " after nine months of pumping. After two years, I am up about 1/2 inch in girth. Not sure it is perminant, but I do know if I take a week or two break from pumping, the additional girth is still there. I do not consider myself a clamper because I only do it several times a month.

[thatnewnew]

not2big why dont you clamp often?