What is considered thick?

[Shady]

Hello,
I have always thought that I have had a below average penis.
My stats are currently 5.8- 6 inches NBPEL and around 5 -5.25 inches in girth (mid shaft).
(sorry my measurements are not consistant, All I have is a piece of flag tape and a tape measurer to get my stats)
Whenever I look at my erect penis it just seems very thin but from the penis charts I have seen I have an above average girth.
The thing is I have made my own porn videos with my girlfriend who is pretty small and my dick just seems small.

At what point would a woman say " Thats a fat cock!" or "Thats thick!"?

[Pegasus]

Depends on the girl ,some might say it at your current size,as you say that's over average.

[MrBigDick]

Hello,
I have always thought that I have had a below average penis.
My stats are currently 5.8- 6 inches NBPEL and around 5 -5.25 inches in girth (mid shaft).
(sorry my measurements are not consistant, All I have is a piece of flag tape and a tape measurer to get my stats)
Whenever I look at my erect penis it just seems very thin but from the penis charts I have seen I have an above average girth.
The thing is I have made my own porn videos with my girlfriend who is pretty small and my dick just seems small.

At what point would a woman say " Thats a fat cock!" or "Thats thick!"?

Dude, does it really matter? If you're fucking her alot and making porn videos with her............shit, who cares. You're getting laid. 5-5.25" around is NOTHING to scoff at.

[Shady]

Well its just I have been PEing in secret and I know I have definately gained in the girth department(probably a 1/4inch).
For the 2 years of being with my girlfriend she never told me I was big or thick.
Im not sure if she just hasnt noticed any gains within the last month or if my girth just isnt that big.

At what point has anybody through out their PE journey been considered thick by women (in terms of girth measurement)?

[PEskeptic]

I have been told that I had a thick penis. My middle girth is about 5 inches as of last month. However, due to the enormity of my mushroom, I think it makes my whole dick feel thicker to women. He plows the way for the rest of the penis.

[going411by7]

A large head is a plus with the women.

[Pegasus]

I started geting told I was thick when I reached 5.25"girth.
I started hearing I was long at my starting 6.75"bpel.
However many girls ,think only the top couple they have ever seen are long thick etc. This can mean you need an extreame measure with very experienced girls. Downright unreasonable if you ask me.

[PEskeptic]

Hearing stuff from girls is completely unreliable. they know nothing about guys penises. seriously. All they have to say is completely subjective.

[iamaru]

I was chubby pre-PE. Not monster chubby, but enough that comments were sometimes made. I started out at 5.5"s around.

[Batwoman]

Hearing stuff from girls is completely unreliable. they know nothing about guys penises. seriously. All they have to say is completely subjective.

That's not a very productive attitude if the whole point is to please women!
Also, may I point out that while each of you has considerable experience, it is usually only with one penis.