Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What exactly constitutes a "thick" member?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What exactly constitutes a "thick" member?

    OK....this may sound like a dumb question but here me out...

    I am starting PE... I know what length goal I want (a solid 8 inches EL .....I'm currently sitting at 6)but I dont know what thickness goal I want. I know I want a thick member but I dont know what 5, or 6 of 7 inches girth looks like. However I'll know what I want when I see it. Its easy to gage length because its linear; there is a "start" and an "end". But with girth it "never ends"...

    Can someone please show me some examples so I know what will be acceptable for myself and know what to strive for.
    Starting
    BPFL: 5"
    NBPFL: 4"
    FL: 4"


    GOAL!...... 8x6.5

  • #2
    thevisualiser [dot] net can help you see what sizes will look like.
    Started Dec 2009: BPEL 6.25 EG 4.50 BPFSL 7.0
    Top Feb 2010: BPEL 7.15 EG 4.50 BPFSL 7.45
    Current Nov 2013: BPEL 7.0 EG 4.5 BPFSL 7.3 (I stopped in summer 2010, starting up again)
    Goal: 8 x 6
    My Log: https://www.pegym.com/forums/progres...-2-2009-a.html

    Comment


    • #3
      very interesting....thanks
      Starting
      BPFL: 5"
      NBPFL: 4"
      FL: 4"


      GOAL!...... 8x6.5

      Comment


      • #4
        anything over 5" is thicker than average... actually according to Mr. Average the median girth from the lifestyles survey is 4.6", that means half are thinner than this and half are thicker. I, personally, agree with Steve. I think if you're over 5.75" you're going to be noticeably thick.

        Comment


        • #5
          ok I know what I want....

          8" EL, 6.5"EG

          So thats an extra 2 inches in length and a 1.5 inches in Girth....

          I just completed my first week.... what do you think is a reasonable time frame? I know we are looking at at least a year here
          Starting
          BPFL: 5"
          NBPFL: 4"
          FL: 4"


          GOAL!...... 8x6.5

          Comment


          • #6
            I don't think there's any way of knowing. There are too many variables. Maybe you can do it in a year, but more than likely it will take years to accomplish that type of goal.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by majic View Post
              ok I know what I want....

              8" EL, 6.5"EG

              So thats an extra 2 inches in length and a 1.5 inches in Girth....

              I just completed my first week.... what do you think is a reasonable time frame? I know we are looking at at least a year here
              Do NOT think much about the time. I would say 3-4 years if you're lucky..
              Log
              Measurements (Current):
              BPEL: 7.25"
              HG: ~6.25"|MEG:6.25"|Low shaft EG:6.5"|BG: 7"

              Comment


              • #8
                Also, I don't know why you set 6.5" girth as your goal. I think anything over 6" girth is just too much. I highly doubt you will find many women who are unsatisfied with 6" of girth.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by PartyPants View Post
                  Also, I don't know why you set 6.5" girth as your goal.

                  Well isnt that always the case? you have varying sizes and goals and if we wanted to we could question every goal...

                  why 8? why not 7? or 6.5?

                  We could do this all day
                  Starting
                  BPFL: 5"
                  NBPFL: 4"
                  FL: 4"


                  GOAL!...... 8x6.5

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    8" X 6" seems to come up most often when one is asked the ideal size.
                    Going411by7 (I was a grower; now I'm a shower).

                    Oct. '03: BPEL 7.75" x 5" Flaccid 4" x 4"
                    Feb. '04: BPEL 10.5" x 7" Flaccid 4" x 4"
                    Oct. '08 BPEL 9.50" x 6" Flaccid 7" x 6"
                    Feb. '09 BPEL 9.50" x 7" Flaccid 7" x 6.5"
                    February '12 BPEL 9.5" x 6" Flaccid 7.5" x 6.25"
                    June '13 BPFLS 11"
                    January '19 BPEL 7" x 6.25" Flaccid 6" x 6.25"
                    December '19 BPEL 7.5" X 6.5" Flaccid 6.5" x 6.5"

                    "It's All Good!" Bob Dylan

                    P.E.: My magnificent obsession

                    "Can't stop! Won't stop! Why stop?!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      I know, but in his original post he stated he wasn't sure what different girths looked like. I just felt he may have been underestimating just how thick 6.5" is.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by PartyPants View Post
                        I know, but in his original post he stated he wasn't sure what different girths looked like. I just felt he may have been underestimating just how thick 6.5" is.
                        Well what I did is I went to that site that was posted in this thread.... then I started playing with sizes and compared them to various porn stars...not because I want to be a porn star, ok guys...but where else am I going to get examples of guys dicks with stats, in action (what does it look like when a girl holds it? blows it? has sex with it?)....and then I asked myself.... would I be happy with that? thats how I came up with 8x6.5

                        but of course I'm not a Nazi with it either....we are dealing with a grey topic here so if I hit 8x6 I wouldnt be complaining
                        Starting
                        BPFL: 5"
                        NBPFL: 4"
                        FL: 4"


                        GOAL!...... 8x6.5

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by majic View Post
                          Well what I did is I went to that site that was posted in this thread.... then I started playing with sizes and compared them to various porn stars...not because I want to be a porn star, ok guys...but where else am I going to get examples of guys dicks with stats, in action (what does it look like when a girl holds it? blows it? has sex with it?)....and then I asked myself.... would I be happy with that? thats how I came up with 8x6.5

                          but of course I'm not a Nazi with it either....we are dealing with a grey topic here so if I hit 8x6 I wouldnt be complaining
                          Haha, you really shouldn't be. When you realize the hard work behind PE you'll be happy to be even 7x5.5.
                          Log
                          Measurements (Current):
                          BPEL: 7.25"
                          HG: ~6.25"|MEG:6.25"|Low shaft EG:6.5"|BG: 7"

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Don't judge by what the alleged dimensions for various pornstars are. The near universal consensus is that they are all overestimated.

                            As for what constitutes enough or too much girth, it depends on what you want to use it for. If you want a wall trophy, well then I guess the bigger the better. If you want a woman to take the thing in her cunny or mouth (let alone her ass) then you might find that there are quite a few women who consider 5" girth enough, 5.5" plenty, and 6" too much.

                            Maybe you should be asking guys who actually have a certain girth what their experiences are? For myself, I am about 5.3" at the glans, 5.6" throughout most of the shaft, and just about 6" right at the base. I have never been too big for a woman's vagina but I have had a couple of lovers who wished I was a little smaller. About a third of the women I have been with have complained of jaw fatique while giving me head. I have never been deep-throated. I have never had anal sex. Tried with a gal once who had done it with other guys and wanted it. Thirty minutes and a lot of lube later we gave it up.

                            Now there will be lots of guys here 6" around or above that they have had no problem with any woman with oral sex, vaginal sex, or even anal sex, but don't think that is going to apply to every woman.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by redbear52 View Post
                              Don't judge by what the alleged dimensions for various pornstars are. The near universal consensus is that they are all overestimated.

                              As for what constitutes enough or too much girth, it depends on what you want to use it for. If you want a wall trophy, well then I guess the bigger the better. If you want a woman to take the thing in her cunny or mouth (let alone her ass) then you might find that there are quite a few women who consider 5" girth enough, 5.5" plenty, and 6" too much.

                              Maybe you should be asking guys who actually have a certain girth what their experiences are? For myself, I am about 5.3" at the glans, 5.6" throughout most of the shaft, and just about 6" right at the base. I have never been too big for a woman's vagina but I have had a couple of lovers who wished I was a little smaller. About a third of the women I have been with have complained of jaw fatique while giving me head. I have never been deep-throated. I have never had anal sex. Tried with a gal once who had done it with other guys and wanted it. Thirty minutes and a lot of lube later we gave it up.

                              Now there will be lots of guys here 6" around or above that they have had no problem with any woman with oral sex, vaginal sex, or even anal sex, but don't think that is going to apply to every woman.
                              Good points made....

                              What I want is a noticably "large dick"...something that is generally considered "large" but at the same time I dont want to totally scare away the girls....I'm not into anal and the idea of deep throat really doesnt do anything for me. I just like good old fashioned sex (oral and vaginal)...doggie, cowgirl and missionary being my favorites.... As far as skill goes I'm considered a good skilled lover (foreplay, technique); I know that if I combine my skill with a good size I'd be sitting pretty...plus its a personal thing for me; I've never had a girl complain about my very average unremarkable penis but I just think 8" and a little more thickness would just look more proportioned on my body/build.

                              Plus, I've had girls that havent seen my dick say... "you look like you would have a large dick" ....meanwhile I'm completely average plain jane....and then I just kinda of back off
                              Starting
                              BPFL: 5"
                              NBPFL: 4"
                              FL: 4"


                              GOAL!...... 8x6.5

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X